Intro

New York City’s Community Preference policy is the subject of an ongoing lawsuit opposing it, Winfield v. the City of New York. Plaintiffs claim that the policy has racially discriminatory impacts and perpetuates the harmful legacy of segregation. Proponents of the policy argue that it is a critical tool to prevent the displacement of low-income residents and communities from neighborhoods where housing costs are rapidly rising.

In 2019, new studies on the impacts of Community Preference surfaced, after being commissioned by Winfield plaintiffs and defendant to substantiate either side’s claims. Does the policy perpetuate segregation? Or does it protect communities of color from displacement? What is the right balance between these complex, and sometimes conflicting policy goals? These are some of the most complex and pressing housing policy challenges facing New York today.

In Community Preference Policy in NYC, CHPC reaches a few key conclusions:

  • The lawsuit around Community Preference raises some of the most pressing challenges facing NYC today, yet the issues at stake are complex and nuanced in ways that can be lost in litigation.
  • The 2019 report on the plaintiff side criticizing Community Preference is highly flawed in methodology, inaccurate, and misleading.
  • Future discussion around these policy issues needs to be preceded by objective analysis, so that it can remain nuanced and grounded in facts.
  • The City needs to make housing lottery data available, with limits in place to protect participant privacy.

Please wait while flipbook is loading. For more related info, FAQs and issues please refer to documentation.

More CHPC publications

Design & Housing Typologies

Twilight Zoning

How slow has housing growth been in NYC's low-density districts? On a per-capita basis, slower than anywhere in the metro area or any other U.S. city.

Find out more
Design & Housing Typologies

Home Truths: A Survey of Unmet Housing Need in Lower-Density Districts

How well is the housing in low-density districts meeting the needs of residents? CHPC asked 805 New Yorkers to find out.

Find out more
Process

Brutal Bureaucracy Follow-up: Additional Housing Connect Analysis

CHPC expands its analysis of affordable housing lease-up times with new, more granular data.

Find out more
Design & Housing Typologies

Basement Apartment Conversion Pilot Program Interim Report

The focus of this interim report is to describe why properties did or did not advance through the pilot and to outline additional changes that would enable the implementation of an effective legalization program at scale.

Find out more
CHPC Global

A tour of six notable refugee housing projects in Europe: a mini-directory

In its directory of housing projects, CHPC describes a range of facilities employed by cities to house refugees, including emergency shelters, temporary housing structures, and short-term and long-term construction projects.

Find out more
Design & Housing Typologies

From Lot to Neighborhood to City: An Action Plan for Basement Flood Safety & Stormwater Equity

CHPC’s new report on basement flood safety & stormwater equity explores possible interventions designed for city-, neighborhood-, and lot-level accountability.

Find out more
Design & Housing Typologies

Onward and Upward: A Technical Guide to Zoning Reform

Onward and Upward offers a detailed guide to the zoning and regulatory changes necessary to create a new housing supply with a focus on affordability, equity, sustainability, and economic recovery.

Find out more
CHPC Global

Participatory Property Management: A Toolkit from the UK

Utilizing Seven National Tenant Engagement Standards from the UK, CHPC has developed a toolkit of options for how public housing residents could productively participate in property management after a PACT conversion.

Find out more